Mental Attribution in Interaction: How the Second Person Perspective dissolves the Problem of Other Minds

  • Antoni Gomila Benejam Universidad de las Islas Baleares
  • Diana Pérez Universidad de Buenos Aires + IIF-SADAF-CONICET
Palabras clave: intersubjetividad, autoconocimiento, segunda persona, otras mentes


In this paper, we will address the question of the impact of the second person perspective of psychological attribution on the traditional problem of knowing other minds. With that purpose in mind, we will introduce the notion of a second-personal perspective of mental attribution within the context of the classical problem of other minds, and discuss the epistemic and ontological implications that follow once the second person perspective is honored. In particular, we will examine how its recognition transforms the traditional problem of other minds, both in its epistemological, ontological and semantical dimensions, and offers a way to go beyond the objective/subjective dichotomy of Modern Philosophy. A proper notion of intersubjectivity, we will argue, is not a simple addition to this dichotomy, but it offers the way to get over the traditional philosophical problems that follow from this modern philosophical paradigm.

Biografía del autor/a

Antoni Gomila Benejam, Universidad de las Islas Baleares
Universidad de las Islas Baleares


Alston, W. (1971) “Varieties of privileged access”. American Philosophical Quarterly 8(3): 223-41.

Avramides, A. (2001) Other Minds. London: Routledge.

Bar-On, D. (2004) Speaking my mind. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bilgrami, A. (2006) Self-Knowledge and resentment. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Butterfill, S. (2012) "Interacting mindsreaders". Philosophical Studies, 165: 841-863.

Cameron, O. G. (2001) Visceral sensory neuroscience: Interoception. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Carruthers, P. (2011) The Opacity of the Mind. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Davidson, D. (1992) "The second person". In P. French (ed.) Midwest Studies in Philosophy, vol. XVII: 255-267.

Davidson, D (2001) Subjective, Intersubjective, Objective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Darwall, S. (2006) The Second Person Standpoint. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Dennett, D. (1987) The Intentional Stance. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Finkelstein, D. H. (2008): Expression and the Inner. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Gallagher, S. (2001: “The practice of the mind: theory, simulation, or primary interaction”, Journal of Consciousness Studies 8, pp. 83-108.

Gallagher, S. (2008) “Embodied social cognition”. In P. Calvo & A. Gomila 2008: Handbook of Cognitive Science: an embodied approach. London: Elsevier, pp. 441-450.

Gallese V. 2005 ‘Being like me’: self-other identity, mirror neurons and empathy. In S Hurley & N Chater (eds.) Perspectives on imitation: from cognitive neuroscience to social science, vol. 1. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, pp. 101 – 118.

Gallese, V. (2016) Bodily selves in relation: embodied simulation as second-person perspective on intersubjectivity. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 369: 20130177.

Goldman, A. (1992) "In defense of the simulation theory". Mind and Language, 7(2):104-119.

Goldman, A. (1993) “The Psychology of Folk Psychology”. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 16

Goldman, A. (2006) The Simulating Mind. The philosophy, psychology and neuroscience of mindreading. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Goldman, A. y Gallese, V. (1998) "Mirror Neurons and the Simulation Theory of Mind-Reading". Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2(12): 493-501.

Gomila, A. (2001) “La perspectiva de segunda persona: mecanismos mentales de la intersubjetividad”. Contrastes, vol. suplementario nº 6: monográfico sobre Filosofía actual de la mente, P. Martínez-Freire, ed., pp. 65-86.

Gomila, A. (2002) "La perspectiva de segunda persona de la atribución mental". Azafea, 1: 123-138.

Gomila, A. (2007) “El retorno de la represión”. Teorema, 26/3: 97-112.

Gomila, A. (2013) “Las emociones en el teatro: ¿por qué nos involucramos emocionalmente con una representación?” En G. Soria Tomás (ed.) La representación de las pasiones: perspectivas artísticas, filosóficas y científicas. Madrid: Dykinson, pp. 57-78.

Gomila, A. & Pérez, D. (2017) “Lo que la segunda persona no es”. En Pérez, D. and Lawler, D. (eds.) Las emociones y la segunda persona. Buenos Aires: SADAF, pp. 275-297.

Gopnik, A. (1993) “How we know our minds: The illusion of first-person knowledge of intentionality”. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 16: 1-15.

Gordon, R. (1986) "Folk Psychology as simulation". Mind and Language, 1(2): 158-171.

Heal, J. (1986/1995) "Replication and Functionalism". Reprinted in M. Davies and T. Stone (eds.) (1995) Folk Psychology. Oxford: Blackwell.

Hirstein, W. (2006): Brain fiction: self-deception and the riddle of confabulation. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Hirstein, W. (2009): Confabulation: views from neuroscience, psiquiatry, psychology and philosophy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Kahneman, D. (2011) Thinking, fast and slow. New York: Farrar, Strauss & Giroux.

Lewis, D. (1966) “An Argument for the Identity Theory”. Journal of Philosophy 63: 17-25.

Lewis, D. (1970) "How to define theoretical terms". The Journal of Philosophy 67(13): 427-446.

Malcolm, N. (1962) “Knowledge of Other Minds”. In V.C. Chappell (ed.) The Philosophy of Mind, Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.

Mill, J.S. (1865) An Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy. London: Longmans.

Nagel, T. (1979) “Subjective and Objective”. In Mortal Questions New York: Cambridge University Press.

Nagel, T. (1986) The view from nowhere. New York: Oxford University Press.

Pérez, D. (2013) Sentir, desear, creer. Una aproximación filosófica a los conceptos psicológicos. Buenos Aires: Prometeo.

Pérez, D. (2014) “Asimetría y conceptos psicológicos”. Páginas de Filosofía, 18: 5-26.

Pérez D. & Gomila, A. (2018) "La atribución mental y la segunda persona". En Balmaceda, T. & Pedace, K. (comps.) Temas de filosofía de la mente: Atribución psicológica. Buenos Aires: SADAF, pp. 69-98.

Reddy, V. (2008) How infants know minds. Harvard, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

Reddy, V. & Morris, P. (2004) "Participants don’t need theories. Knowing minds in engagement". Theory and Psychology, 14: 647-665.

Rizzolatti, G. & Sinigaglia, C. (2010) “The functional role of the parieto-frontal mirror circuit: interpretations and misinterpretations”, Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 11: 264–274

Ryle, G. (1949) The Concept of Mind. London: Hutchinson.

Scheler, M. (1922) Wessen und formen der sympathie. [Esencia y formas de la simpatía. Buenos Aires, Losada 1943, traducción de José Gaos].

Schillbach, L. (2010) “A second-personal approach to other minds”. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 11: 449.

Scotto, C. (2002) "Interacción y atribución mental: la perspectiva de la segunda persona", Análisis Filosófico, vol. XXII, no. 2: 135-151.

Strawson, P. (1959) Individuals. An Essay in Descriptive Metaphysics. Londres: Methuen.

Strawson, P. F. (1962) “Freedom and Resentment” In Gary Watson (ed.), Proceedings of the British Academy, Volume 48: 1962. Oup Oxford. pp. 1-25.

Wittgenstein, L. (1953) Philosophical Investigations. Oxford: Blackwell.

Wright, C. (1998): "Self-knowledge: the Wittgensteinian Legacy", en A. O'Hear, ed.:
Current Issues in Philosophy of Mind (The Royal Institute of Philosophy,
Supplement 43). Cambridge U.P., pp. 101-121.
Cómo citar
Gomila Benejam, A., & Pérez, D. (2018). Mental Attribution in Interaction: How the Second Person Perspective dissolves the Problem of Other Minds. Daimon Revista Internacional De Filosofia, (75).
Perspectivas de 1ª, 2ª y 3ª persona