Identidad nacional y sistema del Convenio Europeo de Derechos Humanos: Una dudosa analogía
Abstract
National identity is an essential legal category in European Union law which has increasingly been invoked by scholars as well as constitutional courts and the Court of Justice of the European Union. In this connection, it is emerging a, still incipient and immature, legal literature which, on the basis of a series of recent judgments coming from the European Court of Human Rights, is interpreting whether there is an analogous figure in the framework of the European Convention of Human Rights system. This article aims to analyse, in a comparative key, the possible advent of the above-mentioned figure in this new legal context.
Downloads
References
BARDUTZKY, S., “The Strasbourg Court on the Dayton Constitution: judgment in the case of Sejdić and Finci v. Bosnia and Herzegovina, 22 December 2009”, European Constitutional Law Review, núm. 6, vol. 2, 2010.
BARENTS, R., “The Court of Justice after the Treaty of Lisbon”, Common Market Law Review, núm. 47, vol. 3, 2010.
BARRERO ORTEGA, A., “El caso Lautsi: la cara y la cruz”, Revista Española de Derecho Constitucional, núm. 94, 2012.
BARILE, P., “Ancora su diritto comunitario e diritto interno”, en AA.VV., Studi per il XX anniversario dell’Assemblea costituente, vol. VI, Vallechi, 1969.
BERNARDI, A., I controlimiti. Primato delle norme europee e difesa dei principi costituzionali, Jovene Editore, Nápoles, 2017.
BESSELINK, L., “National and Constitucional Identity Before and After Lisbon”, Utrecht Law Review, núm. 6, 2010.
BOBEK, M., Comparative Reasoning in European Supreme Courts, Oxford University Press, 2013.
BURGORGUE-LARSEN, L., “L’autonomie constitutionnelle aux prises avec la Convention européenne des droits de l’Homme”, Revue Belge de Droit Constitutionnel, vol.1, 2001.
CLAES, M., “Negotiating Constitutional Identity or Whose Identity is it Anyway”, en CLAES, M., De Visser, M. y Popelier, P. (eds.), Constitutional Conversations in Europe: actors, topics and procedures, Intersentia, 2012.
CLOOTS, E., National Identity in EU Law, Oxford University Press, 2015.
CRUZ VILLALÓN, P., “Unos derechos, tres tribunales”, en CASAS BAHAMONDE, M.E., DURÁN LÓPEZ, F. y CRUZ VILLALÓN, J. (coords.), Las transformaciones del Derecho del Trabajo en el marco de la Constitución europea. Estudios en homenaje al Profesor Miguel Rodriguez-Piñero y Bravo-Ferrer, Wolters Kluwers, 2006.
DÍEZ-PICAZO, L.M., “Observaciones sobre la cláusula de identidad nacional”, en CARTABIA, M., DE WITTE, B. y PÉREZ TREMPS, P. (dirs.), Constitución europea y constituciones nacionales, Tirant lo Blanch, 2005.
EPSTEIN, L. y KNIGHT, J., “Constitutional borrowing and nonborrowing”, International Journal of Constitutional Law, núm. 1, vol. 2, 2003.
FABBRINI, F. y POLLICINO, O., “Constitutional Identity in Italy: European Integration as the Fulfilment of the Constitution”, EUI Working Papers LAW 2017/06, 2017.
FABBRINI, F. y SAJÓ, A., “The dangers of constitutional identity”, European Law Journal, núm. 25, vol. 4, 2019.
GARCÍA ROCA, J., “La muy discrecional doctrina del margen de apreciación nacional según el Tribunal Europeo de Derechos Humanos: soberanía e integración”, Teoría y Realidad Constitucional, núm. 20, 2007.
GARCÍA ROCA, J., El margen de apreciación nacional en la interpretación del Convenio Europeo de derechos humanos: soberanía e integración, Civitas, 2010.
GREER, S., The European Convention on Human Rights. Achievement, Problems and Prospects, Cambridge University Press, 2006.
GREWE, C. y RIDEAU, J. “L’identité constitutionnelle des États membres de l’Union Européenne: flash back sur le coming-out d’un concept ambigu”, en Chemins d’Europe. Mélanges en l’honneur de Jean Paul Jacqué, Dalloz, 2010.
GUASTAFERRO, B., “Beyond the Exceptionalism of Constitutional Conflicts: The Ordinary Functions of the Identity Clause”, Yearbook of European Law, núm. 31, vol. 1, 2012.
JACOBSOHN, G.J., “Constitutional identity”, The Review of Politics, núm. 68, 2006.
KASTANAS, E., Unité et diversité: notions autonomes et marge d’appréciation des états dans la jurisprudence de la Cour Européenne des Droits de l’Homme, Bruylant, 1996.
LÓPEZ GUERRA, L., “National identity and the European Convention on Human Rights”, en SAIZ ARNAIZ, A. y ALCOBERRO LLIVINA, C. (eds.), National Constitutional Identity and European Integration, Intersentia, 2013.
MAHORNEY, P. “Marvellous richness diversity or individual cultural relativism, Human Rights Law Journal, núm. 19, vol. 1, 1998.
MARTÍ, J.L., “Two Different Ideas of Constitutional Identity: Identity of the Constitution v. Identity of the People”, en SAIZ ARNAIZ, A. y ALCOBERRO LLIVINA, C. (eds.), National Constitutional Identity and European Integration, Intersentia, 2013.
MARTINICO, G., “Is It European Convention Going to Be “Supreme”? A Comparative-Constitutional Overview of ECHR and EU Law before National Courts”, European Journal of International Law, núm 23, vol. 2, 2012.
MILLET, F-X., “Constitutional Identity in France: Vices and -Above All- Virtues”, en CALLIES, C. y VAN DER SCHAFF, G., Constitutional Identity in a Europe of Multilevel Constitutionalism, Cambridge University Press, 2020.
MOUTON, J-D., “Vers la reconnaissance d’un droit à l’identité nationale pour les États membres de l’Union?”, en La France, l’Europe et le monde, Mélanges en l’honneur de J. Charpentier, Pedone, 2008.
PESCATORE, P., L’ordre juridique des communautés européennes, Bruylant, 2006.
PONTHOREAU, M-C., “Identité constitutionnelle et clause européenne d’identité nationale. L’Europe à l’épreuve des identités constitutionnelles nationales”, Diritto Pubblico Comparato ed Europeo, 2007.
RIETLING, D., “Le droit au respect à l’identité constitutionnelle nationale”, en BARBATO, J-C. y MOUTON, J-D. (dirs.), Vers la reconaissance de droits fondamentaux aux États membres de l’Union Européenee?, Bruylant, 2010.
ROSENFELD, M., “Constitutional identity”, en ROSENFELD, M. y SAJÓ, A., The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2012.
SAIZ ARNAIZ, A., “L’identité nationale et le droit de l’Union européenne dans la jurisprudence constitutionnelle espagnole” en BURGORGUE-LARSEN, L., L’identité constitutionnelle saisie per les juges en Europe, Pedone, 2011.
SAIZ ARNÁIZ, A. y ALCOBERRO LLIVINA, C., “Why Constitutional Identity Suddenly Matters: A Tale of Brave States, a Mighty Union and the Decline of Sovereignty”, en SAIZ ARNAIZ, A. y ALCOBERRO LLIVINA, C. (eds.), National Constitutional Identity and European Integration, Intersentia, Amberes, 2013.
SCHABAS, W., The European Convention on Human Rights: A Commentary, Oxford University Press, 2015, pp. 902-904.
SCHÜTZE, R., “Three “Bill of Rights” for the European Union”, Yearbook of European Law, núm. 30, vol. 1, 2011.
SIMON, D., “L’identité constitutionnelle dans la jurisprudence de l’Union Européenne”, en BURGORGUE-LARSEN, L. (ed.), L’identité constitutionnelle saisie par les juges en Europe, Pedone, 2011.
SPIELMANN, D., “Allowing the Right Margin: The European Court of Human Rights and The National Margin of Appreciation Doctrine: Waiver or Subsidiarity of European Review”, Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies, núm. 14, 2012.
SZYMCZAK, D., “L’identité constitutionnelle dans la jurisprudence conventionnelle”, en BURGORGUE-LARSEN, Laurence, L’identité constitutionnelle saisie per les juges en Europe, Pedone, 2011.
VAN DE HEYNING, C., “No Place Like Home - Discretionary Space for the Domestic Protection of Fundamental Rights”, en POPELIER, P., VAN DE HEYNING, C. y VAN NUFFEL, P. (eds.), Human Rights Protection in the European Legal Order: The Interaction between the European and the National Courts, Intersentia, 2011.
VAN DER SCHYFF, G., “EU Member State Constitutional Identity”, Zeitschrift für ausslandisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht, núm. 76, 2016.
VIALA, A. “Le concept d’identité constitutionnelle. Approche téorique”, en BURGORGUE-LARSEN, L. (ed.), L’identité constitutionnelle saisie par les juges en Europe, Pedone, 2011.
VON BOGDANDY, A. y SCHILL, S., “Overcoming Absolute Primacy: Respect for National Identity under the Lisbon Treaty”, Common Market Law Review, núm. 48, vol. 5, 2011.
WEILER, J.H.H., The Constitution of Europe. “Do the New Clothes have an Emperor?” and Other Essays on European Integration, Cambride University Press, 1999.
WEILER, J.H.H., “A Constitution for Europe? Some Hard Choices”, Journal of Common Market Studies, núm. 40, vol. 4, 2002.
WICKS, E., “A, B, C vs. Ireland: abortion law under the European Convention”, Human Rights Law Review, núm. 11, vol. 3, 2011.
