The Proposed European Union Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive
Making or breaking European Human Rights Law?
Abstract
The Proposal for a Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence (EU) 2019/1937, COM/2022/71 final, 23 February 2022, ‘CSDDD’) if enacted, would extend responsibilities, liability and exposure to administrative penalties to large economic actors for failure to comply with human rights and environmental obligations. The main purpose of this proposal is to establish a binding set of legal norms to increase access to legal enforcement by linking a breach of the due diligence obligation to public sanctions (Article 20) and civil liability. However, as we analyse in this article, the proposal would significantly limit the scope and content of companies' due diligence as compared to the process foreseen by the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights to which it seeks to give greater effect, while limiting the rights to be protected, and the class of companies obliged to exercise due diligence. At the same time, as we explain, the proposed Directive may jeopardize the integrity of European human rights law as articulated by the judicial and other organs of the Council of Europe, and at the national level
Downloads
Riferimenti bibliografici
ARAI-TAKAHASHI, Y., 'Proportionality', in DINAH S. (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of International Human Rights Law (2013; online edn, Oxford Academic, 16 Dec. 2013).
AUST, H.P. and NOLTE, G. (ed.), The Interpretation of International Law by Domestic Courts: Uniformity, Diversity, Convergence (2016 OUP).
BARBER, N. W. and EKINS, R. ‘Situating Subsidiarity’, The American Journal of Jurisprudence, Volume 61, Issue 1, June 2016, Pages 5–12.
BESSON, S. ‘Subsidiarity in International Human Rights Law—What is Subsidiary about Human Rights?’, The American Journal of Jurisprudence, Volume 61, Issue 1, June 2016, Pages 69–107.
CAROZZA, P. (2003) ‘Subsidiarity as a Structural Principle of International Human Rights Law’. American Journal of International Law, 97(1), 38-79. doi:10.2307/3087103;
CASSEL, D. (2016) ‘Outlining the Case for a Common Law Duty of Care of Business to Exercise Human Rights Due Diligence. Business and Human Rights Journal’ 1(2), 179-202. doi:10.1017/bhj.2016.15
CHRISTOFFERSEN, Jonas and MADSEN M.R. (eds), The European Court of Human Rights between Law and Politics (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2011.
BILCHITZ, D. (2017) ‘Corporate Obligations and a Treaty on Business and Human Rights: A Constitutional Law Model?’ In DEVA, S. & BILCHITZ, D. (Eds.), Building a Treaty on Business and Human Rights: Context and Contours (pp. 185-215). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
CHRISTOFFERSEN, J Fair balance. A Study of Proportionality, Subsidiarity and Primarity in the European Convention on Human Rights (Brill 2009).
HARRIS, O'Boyle, and Warbrick: Law of the European Convention on Human Rights (Fifth Edition, David Harris, Michael O'Boyle, Ed Bates, and Carla M. Buckley, OUP 2023).
JOSEPH, S. Taming the Leviathans: Multinational Enterprises and Human Rights. Neth Int Law Rev 46, 171–203 (1999).
KELLER, Helen and Alec Stone Sweet, Assessing the Impact of the ECHR on National Legal Systems in Helen Keller and Alec Stone Sweet (eds) A Europe of Rights The Impact of the ECHR on National Legal Systems OUP 2008.
LICHUMA, Caroline, Centering Europe and Othering the Rest: Corporate Due Diligence Laws and Their Impacts on the Global South, Völkerrechtsblog, 16.01.2023; id, (Laws) Made in the ‘First World’: A TWAIL Critique of the Use of Domestic Legislation to Extraterritorially Regulate Global Value Chains, 2021 ZaöRV: Zeitschrift für Ausländisches Öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 81 (2), 497-532.
MADSEN, Mikael Rask From Boom to Backlash? The European Court of Human Rights and the Transformation of Europe. /. The European Court of Human Rights: Current Challenges in Historical and Comparative Perspective. red. / Helmut Aust; Demir Esra. Edward Elgar Publishing, 2021
MARTIN-ORTEGA, O and METHVEN O'BRIEN, C (2017), ‘Advancing Respect for Labour Rights Globally through Public Procurement’ Politics and Governance, 5(4), 69-79.
MARTIN-ORTEGA, O and C Methven O’Brien (eds) (2019) Public Procurement and Human Rights: Opportunities, Risks and Dilemmas for the State as Buyer (Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar).
METHVEN O’BRIEN, C (2022): A Defining Moment for the UN Business and Human Rights Treaty Process. In: Verfassungsblog: On Matters Constitutional. Online unter: https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:0301-20221026-110229-0-1.
METHVEN O'BRIEN, C. (2022). Business and human rights and regional systems of human rights protection: applying a governance lens. In A. Marx, J. Wouters, & G. Van Calster (Eds.), Research Handbook on Global Governance and Business and Human Rights (pp. 44-74). (Research Handbooks on Globalisation and the Law series). Edward Elgar Publishing
METHVEN O'BRIEN, C. (2021). Business and human rights in Europe 2011-2021: A decade in review. In P. Czech, L. Heschl, K. Lukas, M. Nowak, & G. Oberleitner (Eds.), European Yearbook of Human Rights 2021 (1 ed.). Intersentia. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3890632
METHVEN O’BRIEN, Business and Human Rights: A Handbook for Legal Practitioners (Council of Europe 2018).
METHVEN O'BRIEN, C. (2018). The Home State Duty to Regulate the Human Rights Impacts of TNCs Abroad: A Rebuttal. Business and Human Rights Journal, 3(1), 47-73
METHVEN O’BRIEN C and DHANARAJAN S, “The corporate responsibility to respect human rights: A status review”, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, Volume 29, Issue 4 (2016), 542-567.
METHVEN O'BRIEN, C., & MARTIN-ORTEGA, O. (2019). Public procurement and human rights: interrogating the role of the state as buyer. In O. Martin-Ortega, & C. Methven O'Brien (Eds.), Public procurement and human rights: Opportunities, risks and dilemmas for the state as buyer (pp. 2-21). (Corporations, Globalisation and the Law series). Edward Elgar Publishing.
METHVEN O’BRIEN C and MARTIN-ORTEGA O (2019), ‘Public procurement and human rights: Discretion, divergence, paradox’ in S Bogojevic, X Groussot and J Hettne (eds), Discretion in EU Procurement Law (Oxford, Hart).
METHVEN O'BRIEN, C and MARTIN-ORTEGA, O. (2020), ‘Human rights and public procurement of goods and services’ in S Deva and D Birchall (eds), Research Handbook on Human Rights and Business, (Cheltenham, Edward Elgar), 245-267.
METHVEN O'BRIEN, C., & Martin-Ortega, O. (2022). Commission proposal on corporate sustainability due diligence: analysis from a human rights perspective. European Union, available at https://www.europarl.europa.eu/thinktank/en/document/EXPO_IDA(2022)702560.
METHVEN O'BRIEN, C., & BOTTA, G. (2023). The Corporate Responsibility to Respect Human Rights: An updated status review (2022). In J. L. da Silva Almeida (Ed.), Responsabilidade Social Corporativa e Governança Socioambiental: Greenwashing e Direitos Humanos (pp. 1-42). Lumen Iuris, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4179257.
METHVEN O'BRIEN, C., & HARTMANN, J. (2022, May 19). The European Commission’s proposal for a directive on corporate sustainability due diligence: two paradoxes. European Journal of International Law. https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-european-commissions-proposal-for-a-directive-on-corporate-sustainability-due-diligence-two-paradoxes/
METHVEN O’BRIEN C and G Holly, “Human rights due diligence laws: Key considerations. Briefing on Civil Liability for Due Diligence Failures” (October 2021, DIHR).
METHVEN O’BRIEN C and NELSON OLOGAHDIEN, ‘Climate Change Mitigation, Investment and Human Rights: The Emerging Legal and Policy Framework?’ in B. Martinez Romera, L. Nordlander and A. Monti (eds), Human Rights and Investment Law for Climate Change: Trends and Prospects (Edward Elgar, in press), available at: https://discovery.dundee.ac.uk/en/publications/human-rights-in-the-context-of-climate-change-emerging-investment ).
METHVEN O'BRIEN, C., & WEATHERBURN, A. (2023). Commission Proposal for a Regulation on prohibiting products made with forced labour on the Union market: The issue of remedies. European Parliament, available at https://www.europarl.europa.eu/thinktank/en/document/EXPO_BRI(2023)702583.
MUCHLINSKI, Peter T. “Human Rights and Multinationals: Is There a Problem?” International Affairs (Royal Institute of International Affairs 1944-), vol. 77, no. 1, 2001, pp. 31–47. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/2626552. Accessed 1 Sept. 2023, pp31-32
NEUMAN, Gerald L., ' Subsidiarity', in Dinah Shelton (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of International Human Rights Law (2013; online edn, Oxford Academic, 16 Dec. 2013)
NOWAK, M. A World Court of Human Rights, in G Oberleitner (ed) International Human Rights Institutions, Tribunals, and Courts (2018. Springer).
PATZ, C. (2022). The EU’s Draft Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive: A First Assessment. Business and Human Rights Journal, 7(2), 291-297. doi:10.1017/bhj.2022.19
RUGGIE, J.G., Sherman, J., (2017), “The Concept of ‘Due Diligence’ in the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: A Reply to Jonathan Bonnitcha and Robert McCorquodale”, European Journal of International Law, Vol. 28, No.3 pp. 921–928, https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chx047,
SAVOUREY, E., & BRABANT, S. (2021). The French Law on the Duty of Vigilance: Theoretical and Practical Challenges Since its Adoption. Business and Human Rights Journal, 6(1), 141-152.
SIMPSON, A. W Brian, Human Rights and the End of Empire: Britain and the Genesis of the European Convention (Oxford, 2004; online edn, Oxford Academic, 1 Jan. 2010).
SPIESSHOFER, B. Supply Chain Due Diligence Law in Germany, Chapter 7 in L Cata Backer and C Methven O’Brien (eds) Human Rights Due Diligence: Emerging Legal Norms and Standards (Routledge, forthcoming).
STOYANOVA, V. (2020). Fault, knowledge and risk within the framework of positive obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights. Leiden Journal of International Law, 33(3), 601-620.
STOYANOVA, Vladislava, Positive Obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights: Within and Beyond Boundaries (June 26, 2022). Forthcoming, Positive Obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights: Within and Beyond Boundaries (Oxford University Press, 2023), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4146695.
UWAFIOKUN, Idemudia Francis Xavier D. Tuokuu, Marcellinus Essah, The extractive industry and human rights in Africa: Lessons from the past and future directions, Resources Policy Volume 78, September 2022, 102838.
VAN DIJK, Pieter, Fried van Hoof, Arjen van Rijn, Leo Zwaak , Theory and Practice of the European Convention on Human Rights, 5th edition, 2018, Intersentia.
WOUTERS, Jan, and Michal Ovádek, The European Union and Human Rights: Analysis, Cases, and Materials (Oxford, 2021; online edn, Oxford Academic, 22 July 2021).
Copyright (c) 2023 Annals of Law
Questo lavoro è fornito con la licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 4.0 Internazionale.
Las obras que se publican en esta revista están sujetas a los siguientes términos:
1. El Servicio de Publicaciones de la Universidad de Murcia (la editorial) conserva los derechos patrimoniales (copyright) de las obras publicadas, y favorece y permite la reutilización de las mismas bajo la licencia de uso indicada en el punto 2.
2. Las obras se publican en la edición electrónica de la revista bajo una licencia Creative Commons Reconocimiento-NoComercial-SinObraDerivada 3.0 España (texto legal). Se pueden copiar, usar, difundir, transmitir y exponer públicamente, siempre que: i) se cite la autoría y la fuente original de su publicación (revista, editorial y URL de la obra); ii) no se usen para fines comerciales; iii) se mencione la existencia y especificaciones de esta licencia de uso.
3. Condiciones de auto-archivo. Se permite y se anima a los autores a difundir electrónicamente las versiones pre-print (versión antes de ser evaluada) y/o post-print (versión evaluada y aceptada para su publicación) de sus obras antes de su publicación, ya que favorece su circulación y difusión más temprana y con ello un posible aumento en su citación y alcance entre la comunidad académica. Color RoMEO: verde.
